娛樂滿紛 26FUN - Powered by Discuz! Board

標題: 對香港既流行曲有咩感覺 [打印本頁]

作者: 冰封騎士 時間: 2005-2-27 12:51 AM 標題: 對香港既流行曲有咩感覺

我覺得曲唔係差詞就好唔掂
咩咩做隻貓做隻狗不做情人

作者: Miz 時間: 2005-2-27 01:02 AM

我一向唔聽廣東歌...質素差到嘔...歌就一般(曲真的不錯~詞就...) ~歌手又....唉
好似求其係街汁件蛋散上台唱歌咁..= =' l0 o6 s7 {9 _4 T
so..我now都只聽日本的~零願麻煩一點去看歌詞(日本的歌詞很有意思)~好過聽 hk 的

作者: fing86 時間: 2005-2-27 11:39 AM

香港無樂壇...淨係得班小丑坤細路錢...

作者: drunknmunky911 時間: 2005-2-27 02:08 PM

Just Like A Copycat~7 r8 T x1 I9 @8 f
Jap 有早晨娘~HK 出個Cookies
US 有Evanescence~HK 就出個Ping ping

真係比人笑到臉都黃

作者: Miz 時間: 2005-2-27 02:36 PM

Originally posted by drunknmunky911 at 2005-2-27 02:08 PM:/ n; Y& H- N- Q) O) B+ l) g
Just Like A Copycat~
$ r( Q, d4 k: u- p) N- ^; e, R7 uJap 有早晨娘~HK 出個Cookies9 X4 z1 x8 f% n, ]$ n
US 有Evanescence~HK 就出個Ping ping6 T* C; ~, [6 G4 U/ r( m" ]# H0 n. M

0 U( x% n( f! Q) s真係比人笑到臉都黃

我都有同感~!! Cookies 之前一組就組九個人...但好似冇個唱得咁 ~抄晒Morning娘6 F9 C Z# G( b! Q, c
但Morning 有實力好多 (雖然並唔係個個都一定唱得掂..但話晒都係選出黎)
$ i) N2 a* f* ], D3 e, E# B
仲有呀...HK果個咩e-kid (忘了名啦==) 我feel係想抄w-inds..

作者: brightlee 時間: 2005-2-27 03:30 PM

When u guys are blaming the songs are too commerical... think deeply.. who makes this??0 R8 S  t6 L8 [2 F- u8 C5 j& J

Who would be listening one style, only "love" songs?

I was growing up in 80s to 90s,  i6 E7 i; A) {! y
When I was in 80s, there were so many good singers, (well, look at Paula Tsui, Sam Hui... when they say, they would like to go back to music media, how many people are having "hope" for them?% @; I7 O& b8 l2 a* e5 A

There are several ways that .. the musics are going backwards
! J6 H8 z& m7 r/ o
1) I explained in other post before, which is talking about singers. Who is a real singer in reality nowadays? (I mean.. how many of them, they could sing it well?! pls don't say to me the answer is Twins. Thanks)5 W1 V6 g% r. C$ q" X: W, g
: q  \/ {- y4 Y( ?9 }
2) Karaoke, you may be surprising, but this it truth..
When you look back the time track, the Karaoke is started in around 1990s, see, the singers of that generation, starting to going downwards.... cos if one song would like to be popular, easy lyrics, easy melody, people could sing it easily in Karaoke.....

3) Laziest for OUR Cantonese people
Give you an example, when we sing songs, (think it in your heart deeply) do you real the lyrics, and find out what's that means?
more than 99%, including me, never think about it.. just think the songs get a good "feel" then sing it.. and love it...

4) Can't accpet another types of songs except "love": M3 R/ n) `! c- ~
In 70s and 80s, even in 90s, some songs... were talking about love in family, school, friends, but nowadays, do you think about your family so deep? do you think about your schoolmates deeply? would you think and sing with your real friends?
Seems getting less and less.. and just thinking love from "boys and girls" are more important than everything/ U3 b3 M1 W* b; j: X$ J( C
. Y; J3 v3 o5 f2 l3 V7 g1 |: F: n% v
Give you an example, "friends" from Alan Tam, this song is about 20 years ago, I am seriously talking about, 20 years ago, but how many songs are talking friendship, which could be popular in this 20 yrs? Not much...  (at least I could remember in my memories)
& z+ k' ^2 R% ^4 p1 N8 f! j
( u  X6 n! k) ]6 Z% I- P: c
I think it's a good time to think back about our life.
If you are blaming the lyrics, singers are not that good.. # B: F& t$ s0 C0 |  b8 y5 W
We are the cus---ers.............. of the music media... we choose the songs... then why we don't upgrade ourself first, to let singers to know what types of songs we would like to listen?: x# L! a( p5 o1 T
* H9 e4 s" F+ D

+5
1 G9 T1 {- H0 P, X! d
[ Last edited by 樂壇渣Fit人 on 2005-2-27 at 11:06 PM ]

作者: 甘國武 時間: 2005-2-27 04:23 PM

Originally posted by drunknmunky911 at 2005-2-27 02:08 PM:: A. p; A$ q9 h
Just Like A Copycat~
. O" ]6 o0 V0 `" W8 \Jap 有早晨娘~HK 出個Cookies
2 M# E: l0 m, u5 ]; jUS 有Evanescence~HK 就出個Ping ping
1 x# ?# D* @" L! B+ z6 I2 L! b
& |- `' @4 Y4 R( j/ V: D真係比人笑到臉都黃

% ~+ G) \' \0 T" \- w3 l8 \
TW 有FIR~HK 就出個Ping ping

作者: sugizo_esp 時間: 2005-2-27 07:10 PM

FIR is copy Japan's Do As Infinity i think~ or Globe

作者: davyloh 時間: 2005-2-27 07:50 PM

我覺得係唔係 copy 日本或外國唔係咁重要, 音樂這家野唔多唔少會互相參考!
最重要本身音樂質素, 做得好自然有人喜歡% f* L+ ?, G; d5 [. d4 F* D
可惜香港所謂樂壇唔多重視音樂, 注重外表多.......
你睇d 留言板講 cookies 多數媽媽聲' j: y* j) U1 T& x+ X& u
講 FIR 就話唱得好聽
呢d 咪香港槳壇囉

作者: 甘國武 時間: 2005-2-27 07:57 PM

你睇d 留言板講 cookies 多數媽媽聲( |" t" O' s* h. g/ G$ J! c
講 FIR 就話唱得好聽
7 ]: U2 I: w' f5 l; t呢d 咪香港槳壇囉

難道你不認為 FIR是好聽一點？! A9 b) k) N9 ?! S) f6 I0 e4 ]
(不過，我認為cookies也ok~)

作者: KrisX 時間: 2005-2-27 08:12 PM

我聽呢d 歌, 多數只聽音樂, 不聽歌詞.( h4 @4 y/ ]" K% w" x6 g
so 我覺得d cd 應該出多d 純音樂版

作者: Miz 時間: 2005-2-27 10:16 PM

Originally posted by KrisX at 2005-2-27 08:12 PM:
O( \+ [! y6 s/ o; C% |$ ] 我聽呢d 歌, 多數只聽音樂, 不聽歌詞.
8 L$ [0 ~! c0 H! V& dso 我覺得d cd 應該出多d 純音樂版

+ q$ G9 c% o' q
; K% E1 p3 J' q1 ^5 v8 V
又係呀~我聽 hk既聽完就算..唔會理歌詞...更何況佢差在冇"Instrumenta"
次次出碟唔係專輯就係大碟..下下一次過出十幾首~質素唔差就奇, ]4 K3 N+ f `: x6 y6 }" y
0 Z6 o$ E2 A ?. i& M' ]+ a
日本d細碟就一定有既~我有時真係like聽Instrumenta多過聽原歌~

(若有講錯sry先)

作者: whitebase 時間: 2005-2-28 03:15 AM

Originally posted by drunknmunky911 at 2005-2-27 02:08 PM:
$ Q, k7 f, I' Q- z; J& P2 J Just Like A Copycat~
: b3 t# d2 t6 K7 x1 @! A7 lJap 有早晨娘~HK 出個Cookies
5 L3 @' h1 I" T: G- c, `US 有Evanescence~HK 就出個Ping ping# \( x) o: u0 Y

: p$ C) c. J; s' c真係比人笑到臉都黃

早晨娘都o吾係好架la，都要抄，抄又抄o吾都一地D精粹
受仔的英Ｘ仲好似Johnny時務所一樣& m, T1 \9 T! J% _" A! `
無眼睇........
燐伯又成日真係年年25咁，打下Goft咪好law
講咩新4大天皇鴉，自己Star East 又做o吾起摺鬼左.......( M- K) E1 _# D# a* Y
歌手又要睇晒無線頭，又o吾敢得罪佢仲成日要做D唱歌以外的JOB...* h0 ~: d) F( V: @$ J; W; f
香港地事場又細，又得無線一個平台，音樂節目點有進步wor) Z: |% [* `: y$ W
F.I.R 都lose 比垃圾Twins

仲有咩好Say!!!

But 廣東話發音實在太平實，沒有高低起伏- ?6 `. e8 p E# A! H. X
o吾同英，日，國語發音好聽，所以比較難處理& a1 u- ?! h! l$ U5 V8 P+ i
歌手自己又o吾全面，大部份只係o向K場房歌得下就諗住自己好掂，之後入行！
學下人地日本la.......o吾係歌手o向街唱都有Fans嫁/ S9 g% P3 V' l# B

K場就係主流，老實講....早前森美小儀的K僅四十D參實者仲唱得好過原唱者 `( v& l: j# T
唉.......我都無氣Say low

作者: d228216 時間: 2005-2-28 11:34 AM

(quote)
But 廣東話發音實在太平實，沒有高低起伏' t8 x& D9 M W4 l9 C
o吾同英，日，國語發音好聽，所以比較難處理; ^5 y9 f; r" z) ~( @( e
1 N* F. [( D8 Z" x
全世界得廣東話發音有9聲階(同一個字有9個音)
% ^) R, S5 `6 l9 F6 {0 U
計我話:' u) l* y! c& z9 r
一週-令香港新聞界PK
英皇-令香港娛樂界PK
肥董-令香港政治界PK3 H# D0 _: `7 ?% _% h1 I, L7 ?
梁英-令香港地產界PK& ]6 p4 Y) A2 U% a
盧婆-令香港房屋界PK
大班-令香港廣播界PK
民主黨-令香港PK界更PK' ]2 B l: @! L( S8 i2 P

......大x把

作者: d228216 時間: 2005-2-28 11:36 AM

(qoute)
K場就係主流，老實講....早前森美小儀的K僅四十D參實者仲唱得好過原唱者
唉.......我都無氣Say low8 Y9 b; j& h( }. [# Y/ V' Q1 `
) t0 z. `& H9 Y) L5 D/ j7 L( c
support and 大x把啦

作者: brightlee 時間: 2005-2-28 11:43 AM

(quote), t- c  r; o; K. {  [- W- g
But 廣東話發音實在太平實，沒有高低起伏
o吾同英，日，國語發音好聽，所以比較難處理
" `& q6 ?  R* g1 s
Sorry, do u know when Cantonese gets  9 voice tones, which is great? cos we can change the lyrics (not one format of lyrics) and get some good meanings in there?!
- H2 R* T; O! Z" P- R
"吾同英，日，國語發音好聽"
There should be NO different!!! it's all depends for the singers and the writers (of the lyrics)
Do u think 70s or 80s Cantonese songs get no meanings in there?
Why you could still listen it in the radio/TV sometimes?!!
Why singers are sing some OLD songs again?!!
Why many people in HK are so upset when James Wong, Anita Mui and Roman Tam were pass away?! # @4 n5 ?. i2 `/ n- l, w

Come'on, wake up pls, don't blame Cantonese (language) is not that good..
What's your comments,
it maybe an excuse for OURSELVES

[ Last edited by brightlee on 2005-2-28 at 01:52 PM ]

作者: austin666 時間: 2005-2-28 02:25 PM

Originally posted by 冰封騎士 at 2005-2-27 12:51 AM:0 U ~3 `4 `. \. U( x
我覺得曲唔係差詞就好唔掂; f7 [- }+ L) q
咩咩做隻貓做隻狗不做情人

# u( ]" x8 ^1 o; d0 o/ w8 G
d曲更係吳錯啦9 P. @/ {9 \" f

好多吳係改篇外國的
就係抄足7-80%然後當自己作
有d作曲人仲抄人都吳認

當我地呢d聽外國歌的人死的 J* Z% Q* \* D0 j) D" o0 W
吳係聾的都聽得出佢抄都仲死口吳認

作者: austin666 時間: 2005-2-28 02:33 PM

[quote]Originally posted by d228216 at 2005-2-28 11:34 AM:4 Q: W$ `2 m1 [) ? B
(quote)
計我話:
一週-令香港新聞界PK (雜誌界)
英皇-令香港娛樂界PK (歌壇)" H" g* l/ R) H3 M% i
肥董-令香港政治界PK (全港)7 t' L& m9 G+ u$ L9 D5 S0 C* i# o" b
梁英-令香港地產界PK (全港市民身家)
盧婆-令香港房屋界PK (係房屋..........處即). T" U$ w8 N8 U8 ^ y* B5 V' O
大班-令香港廣播界PK (冇左佢係商台pk即)' }' m7 x' G: L
民主黨-令香港PK界更PK(3大黨都係無個好人一樣咁pk)! B+ z$ H1 @' N# ?9 b& a

咁改就差不多............

作者: brightlee 時間: 2005-2-28 02:38 PM

Originally posted by austin666 at 2005-2-28 16:33:
) W! l" u4 m# o0 V [quote]Originally posted by d228216 at 2005-2-28 11:34 AM:
2 @ q" x3 [; }9 [3 g2 T/ }$ ]2 N (quote)2 w0 B" n0 M* v+ l |: y! G- l7 ^
計我話:
$ D" \2 j$ J7 m" y, @0 Y一週-令香港新聞界PK (雜誌界)- y1 l* Z3 x( s1 V: _9 ^- u( ^/ x
英皇-令香港娛樂界PK (歌壇)
+ A0 V1 x& p3 C" P% q肥董-令香港政治界PK (全港): |* }1 a, E& A1 ?, G' J
梁英-令香港地產界P ...

( G' c& b+ O4 B+ L

I support your msg!!! [6 {) P2 d! Y( ]% B' {! b
0 r9 H# F+ ]4 `
hahahha.. you think deeply what's happen in HK actually!!

作者: drunknmunky911 時間: 2005-3-1 12:21 AM

Originally posted by austin666 at 2005-2-28 02:25 PM:! A8 v! Q4 h/ |8 A8 X

3 [" J0 p0 o! d. k7 w+ v7 X7 K; E2 U0 u5 s9 V3 A* z. S; ^

3 C9 ?/ V+ r. P: d; Y/ f
- g% G8 f1 C* W4 H% K& ?1 F, Cd曲更係吳錯啦, u+ @, ?1 ]& m

9 b6 X/ l3 C3 H' | G) P好多吳係改篇外國的; J+ ?" c& S; j. \
就係抄足7-80%然後當自己作* l& L+ ]- }- v$ `
有d作曲人仲抄人都吳認5 W8 F" C# _$ H) e* Z

F$ c* ? ]* m# n當我地呢d聽外國歌的人死的/ H( l# r; ?8 c2 D
吳係聾的都聽得出佢抄都仲死口吳認

; {) t, P a% F: X. U' N
1 ~4 ~) k! D) _$ n$ t* a2 _
Totally Agree!!!!!: L# K) u' Y7 ^* W
真係好討厭!!!!!
佢地自己握自己!!!!!

作者: drunknmunky911 時間: 2005-3-1 12:31 AM

我覺得香港咩都鍾意抄~又唔識抄~
好似細個番學校抄同學功課~連人地個名都抄埋~

作者: thatsok 時間: 2005-3-1 12:49 AM

我都覺得詞唔掂，來來去去都講愛情，而且好俗。
寧願聽日文歌好過，淨係聽首曲都夠爽。

作者: jctk2419 時間: 2005-3-1 09:55 AM

What means of lyrics ??????????

作者: brightlee 時間: 2005-3-1 11:02 AM

hai.... Lyrics means 歌詞
( d. q9 u9 _5 q, P& \' s

it's time for learn more English.......) l6 l {6 J/ l+ t* W" Z
otherwise .. how can you survive in other place except HK?!

歡迎光臨娛樂滿紛 26FUN (http://www.26fun.com/bbs/)