秋葉林

Originally posted by research2005010 at 2005-7-15 16:32:
假設挪亞方舟確實存在, 而又證明到呢隻船確實是用來躲避滅絕人類的洪水，都只能夠證明猶太教, 天主教或基督教, 或者錫安教等信阿當夏娃的宗教其中一個是真的, ...

先唔講科唔科學，就算證明到挪亞方舟確實存在，咪最多話證明到「挪亞方舟」單嘢嘅可信性高咗，點都唔可以咁就話天主教、基督教 ... 係堅嘅，邏輯上完全唔 work。

唔通話有人舉報阿邊個邊個用把刀殺咗人，家陣證明到把刀係殺人凶器，就可以判阿邊個邊個有罪咩，完全唔合邏輯。

rest365days

Originally posted by 秋葉林 at 2005-7-15 05:23 PM:
先唔講科唔科學，就算證明到挪亞方舟確實存在，咪最多話證明到「挪亞方舟」單嘢嘅可信性高咗，點都唔可以咁就話天主教、基督教 ... 係堅嘅，邏輯上完全唔 work。

唔通話有人舉報阿邊個邊個用把刀殺咗人，家陣證明到把刀係殺人凶器，就可以判阿邊個邊個有罪咩，完全唔合邏輯。

100%同意, 宗教信仰係無可能証明嘅
成日停留喺考古, 分析, 驗證嘅階段, 完全唔明白, 唔理會對方嘅教義同埋經文所表達嘅內容, 只係浪費時間.

[ Last edited by rest365days on 2005-7-15 at 05:51 PM ]

kerr

Originally posted by research2005010 at 2005-7-15 04:43 PM:
據我所知猶太教, 天主教, 基督教等等...

緆安教唔係分支,而係異端

slwong3

Originally posted by pyliu at 2005-7-15 05:08 PM:

哈哈！
其實係唔同民族、宗教、國...

不過有D人就會結論為世界上真係有一次好大既洪水，我唔排除呢個可能性，但係我比較認同另一重睇法！

actually I don't quite understand.....
even there is 大洪水, how is it related to the God?
in bible, it's saying that the God gave hints to 挪 亞 that there would be 洪水 coming and asked him to build 方 舟
I have watched the movie about it in the church (I'm not a believer)
but I don't quite believe in that.......
there is no proof of saying that 挪 亞 built the 方 舟 because of the God telling him to do so

research2005010

假設挪亞方舟確實存在, 而又證明到呢隻船確實是用來躲避滅絕人類的洪水

所以我加多左一個condition, 即係想講唔只洪水發生過, 挪亞件事都係真的, 希望會好d, 不過表達得唔夠樓上咁清楚

[ Last edited by research2005010 on 2005-7-15 at 09:26 PM ]

dl.dennis

Originally posted by rest365days at 2005-7-15 05:40 PM:


100%同意, 宗教信仰係無可能証明...

要証明嘅話.只要你相信衪.就會知道衪是又真又活的神

justin_lun

基督教和天主教是互相承認彼此的真確的﹐也就是說﹐都承認彼此能夠得救﹑上天堂。

geese

其實大家有冇睇過呢套片?
我睇完之後只係發覺完來係未証實揾到方舟,
套戲最尾個段成班人淨係講確信方舟就係雪下面
同有神蹟出現.......

justin_lun

这段片确实未能证明方舟的存在，但起码有了一个可研究的方向，算是找寻圣经实证的另一个开端。

research2005010

Originally posted by justin_lun at 2005-7-16 02:53 AM:
基督教和天主教是互相承認彼此的真確的﹐也就是說﹐都承認彼此能夠得救﹑上天堂。

據我所知, 天主教徒因為贖了原罪, 有機會在審判日因為一生善功多過惡行所以上到天堂, 並非承認一信就上天堂