略說反「何文匯正音」本末

magic

......轉貼.......7 h% Z# E" U5 [( ~" h# N* b: y: f
0 B$ L& G$ r; f+ T! O
略說反「何文匯正音」本末
& R! d% c, A* o8 t5 E+ S6 a  V, [& V, ~% u( g
9 k* t2 S! l  c# s" a, |, B
傳媒新聞部的人，怕讀錯字音，這本來是負責任的態度。可是，他們卻給何文匯鑽了空子，誤將他提倡的讀音作為標準，根本不知道他違反學術原則，漠視廣府話的種種語源。
& _* {; I  R# L4 v1 @
* Z$ b8 |8 X! ^) p% n' |. ^2 B; P當年何文匯的老師劉殿爵提倡「時奸」，王亭之立即抨擊，令其「正音」失敗。他在中文大學出錄音帶，給中小學教師「正音」，王亭之指出錄音帶有過百錯誤，中文大學說要告王亭之誹謗，過了兩年，則改為來信給王亭之要求更正，因為經過覆核，只有七八十處錯誤而已。經此事後，「正音」又無疾而終。' V/ T6 X8 f( f

3 {  O" H4 t, W, c7 b! p王亭之八六年往夷島定居，到九三年回港，才知道何文匯將「正音」搞到如此成功。因為夷島資訊隔涉，所以何文匯便無敵手。' @0 W5 h9 R8 Y& r' J7 ?

3 C. \5 v! ]7 K7 O2 c8 ?: u後來王亭之來圖麟都定居，當邪音初出現時，曾跟蘇凌峰先生、何潔貞女士提出讀音問題，但反應冷淡，他們根本沒興趣跟王亭之討論。蘇凌峰甚至以「語音七十年一變」為理由，反對王亭之的說法，這是昧著良心的理由。因為他分明是跟何文匯的讀音，而何文匯則白紙黑字承認他是根據一千年前的《廣韻》。不承認「語音七十年一變」的正是何文匯，而不是王亭之。. X6 m, n" F. S

! q) [' U; T" x: t如今王亭之將事情本末略為提出，很希望兩家電視台思考，因為此事可大可小。: m8 Q3 b) k! H- c) c0 h$ q6 \1 \
2 ~- X8 P0 Q. d+ C/ ?) `' q8 N5 P
[ Last edited by magic on 2007-1-2 at 01:05 PM ]

kiuken

何文匯
+ U: I. m' B/ i9 N4 f2 s比佢吹脹( C& m* q$ g5 H5 f. `+ D
都唔知佢d讀音點黎!

magic

Originally posted by kiuken at 2007-1-2 05:42 PM:
; h& ^7 Z8 g1 K" u何文匯! x% e* L5 T7 Z( l4 `- X
比佢吹脹
, t# k( D  P1 w都唔知佢d讀音點黎!

) Z( N  f" K+ K* D; o- B, b" T何文匯是根據一千年前的《廣韻》，不承認「語音七十年一變」....畀佢吹能...脹

阿感

個"時奸"亂咁 "提唱",唯恐天下不亂

ryankwok13

I don't like this so call Prof Ho...so news said his PhD is not on the related field. So wht's is his phD belongs to

darkhunter

Originally posted by magic at 2007-1-2 06:46 PM:+ P5 ~/ Y2 [% G8 D' @$ {  ]
" h- m6 a* z/ ?% t
何文匯是根據一千年前的《廣韻》，不承認「語音七十年一變」....畀佢吹能...脹

$ o& l0 |0 ]4 W' Z2 F4 o- _# B* r2 G6 p: T
1千年前已經有廣東話....9 ~1 o# u* q  s$ V: M
真係勁
3 h7 b9 D' |2 a0 P1 X4 N7 z5 L' vhttp://www.bookstrg.com/shtml/Reading/YHCH/101.htm" X% _/ ~, w; o$ p
1 c  f4 P& b7 A, h2 ^5 K8 Y
[ Last edited by darkhunter on 2007-1-3 at 09:47 AM ]

magic

Originally posted by darkhunter at 2007-1-3 09:44 AM:
+ K9 u# j: S. w) e$ Q/ \/ O! W
7 u+ r, K) P, j* m
& T4 Y2 N0 C. e" L- l+ E1千年前已經有廣東話....7 T# i" |4 R1 X# t5 A6 }
真係勁
! A$ N" c& H! A) [% \http://www.bookstrg.com/shtml/Reading/YHCH/101.htm
' m7 e/ `5 g: F; W9 _) _9 r% t% {6 C. r' Z* D
[ Last edited by darkhunter on 2007-1-3 at 09:47 AM ]

5 G) C$ s) S& W! A; r
thx....

magic

Originally posted by darkhunter at 2007-1-3 09:44 AM:+ B8 ]1 j6 s/ W6 c& w) z. o

% I* D9 @" \. f+ j. h* j0 y+ e' S; n# e& x
1千年前已經有廣東話....
4 V( H$ \3 E/ E3 [真係勁
/ F' U6 }9 P* s3 I2 g1 shttp://www.bookstrg.com/shtml/Reading/YHCH/101.htm  ^+ v& s" @/ B3 {3 r0 v
6 r: S! K# K% O( I" {
[ Last edited by darkhunter on 2007-1-3 at 09:47 AM ]

# Q/ m" I" W! P現在無記之所謂[[[正字]]]...要小心...有D係[[何卜st]] 的錯野..小心!!!

magic

Originally posted by ryankwok13 at 2007-1-3 12:39 AM:
! Z3 ~6 L; _8 g# L# TI don't like this so call Prof Ho...so news said his PhD is not on the related field. So wht's is his phD belongs to

9 l5 H1 v8 ]  H* J- y2 x* y0 P2 g5 H8 e
有冇人有何文匯的相...??thx...昨日去鵝頸橋...个阿婆話有相會好D..thx...各位大佬幫幫忙..

esterqwerty

Originally posted by magic at 2007-1-4 02:04 AM:
7 g; [9 A8 T8 t
( }! Z& V7 v8 i9 j- l5 \" R現在無記之所謂[[[正字]]]...要小心...有D係[[何卜st]] 的錯野..小心!!!

/ \' ?" c; A. R, P

' b& G- x1 X: m; l9 Q- n+ r5 m7 K# P* N. M3 d! {
"正字"有佢出現過ma?